You can score the fat cap, I just sliced deep into the fat to allow the seasoning to get into the crevices, which worked perfect for me.
Rub seasoning deep into the meat
Big Green Egg
Setup: Pretty simple with the inverted plate setter, I placed my drip tray on top of the convEggtor and the standard grill plate on top of everything, resting on the plate setter.
I set up my BGE for indirect cooking
Once I put the pork butt on the egg – after I get the egg to hold at 225 – I gave the pork butt another generous coating of the rub.
Cook Time
I consistently checked the temp of the BGE keeping an even 225-250, the butt cooked for just about 9 hours slowly. I rubbed every couple hours with more seasoning.
After a total cook time of 9 hours, I raised the Egg temperature to 300 for the final 1 hour to make sure the bark got nice and crispy. My butt was at 195 after all of this and I tested the meat by moving the thermometer – it slide in nice and easy.
We sliced our butt, but tomorrow we will shred and add some BBQ sauce or something amazing to compliment this pork butt for our weekly meal prep
Notes
You don't need a barbecue master's certificate to make a mean pork butt. Follow these tips from Mr. Squeeze and you'll be cooking like your favorite pitmaster in no time!